Bookmark and Share

Struggling Home Owners Loan Modifications Turned Down Because Too Affordable

by Andrew on August 26, 2009

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

You know there is something wrong with a system when those that need it don’t qualify. This seems to be the case with the Home Affordable Modification Program. One of the main reasons home owners are turned down is because their loans, by the Home Affordable Modification Program standards, are too affordable.

How is it decided if a loan is too affordable to qualify?

One of the main factors is the percentage of the household income that is dedicated to pay the mortgage. If 31% or more of the household income is set aside for the mortgage and other criteria is also satisfied then the home owners qualifies for the loan modification. However if the percentage of the household income is lower it is too bad.

When this criteria was decided it seemed a reasonable percentage of a household income. It was actually seen as a turn back to old fashioned conservative times when workers where only expected to put one week of their wages toward their housing. Apparently it was in the times of the railway “explosion” that workers were given housing by the railway company in exchange for one week of wages.

However this measure has turned out to be just that, old fashioned. People nowadays don’t only owe money on their homes, also on their cars, their credit cards. In fact credit card debts are right at the top in the catalysts for bankruptcy.

Forbes website reported that William Erbey, chief executive of Ocwen, the second largest U.S subprime mortgage servicer says his borrowers are often saddled with credit card bills and auto loans and will pay those bill before their home loans. William Erbey feels that “ It’s not their mortgage that is out of whack. It’s that their other consumption patterns are out of whack”.

This opinion will ring true for many that have seen how a consumerist culture has moved more and more people to get deeper into debt as a matter of course.
Others criticize the administration and government institutions for being out of touch with reality. Forbes also reported that Chief Executive Sanjiv Das chided policymakers by saying: “This is people solving for a housing crisis not realizing we’re in a credit crisis”.

These comments and the slow start of the Home Affordable Modification Program indicates that it might be the program itself that is ready for modification. A program that worked on the overall debt of a household would provide more practical help than just focusing on one of the debts of this credit crisis. One of the biggest hurdles the government have to overcome is training people to spend sensibly not only provide the cash to pay the debts.

Last 3 posts by Andrew

Related posts:

  1. $75 Billion Making Home Affordable Loan Modification Program Gets To Work
  2. Loan Modifications Only Hope For American Dream
  3. Keep Your Finances Afloat With Suitable Loan Modifications
  4. What Is A Home Loan Modification
  5. HUD Expands Making Home Affordable Eligibility

  • cuijinfu
    The fact that we're bailing out any homeowners at all is a travesty. But now you're trying to make people feel sorry for morons who went above and beyond taking out a stupid mortgage but also ran up credit card bills and car loans irresponsibly? You've got to be kidding. People who can't afford to pay 31% of their income don't deserve to keep the house. Home ownership is not some sort of fundamental right and there's no shame in renting. I'm a renter and have yet to see 1 cent of stimulus or bailout payola and it enrages me when people imply my tax dollars should go to bailing out someone who is living beyond their means.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post: Loan Modifications and FHA Refinance What Is The Deal